^ That's intense I think it goes like this: I guard Gerb, Gerb checks me. If Gerb ends up dead, and I claim roleblock, Gav will refute it. One of us is lying, now the blame-game is played until we get a decision. I guard Gerb, Gerb checks me, I end up dead. Gerb then can confirm me as Town (or claim Mafia if we are rolling with the Face Stealing theory). I guard Gerb, Gerb checks me, we both live. I am town (confirmed by Gerb), and most likely Gaverion is too for not stopping such a big thing. Gav would be committing potential Mafia suicide if he didn't stop this. Someone else dies to the NK, probably Xinde. If Gerb and I live, he checks me and reveals Mafia OR Gerb dies from a NK (Only if I get roleblocked, so go see point 1) then I am to be lynched. If nothing above happens, the Mafia is in Gav or KTC (Jad is dead at this point via Xinde). If ANYONE dies outside of the NK, then Xinde is confirmed as Town. If Xinde dies to the NK, but KingJad lives, then that means Gaverion blocked him and should be lynched for anti-town actions. This also incriminates KingJad. I think I got them all....
If gerben dies there are two possibilities: Gaverion is mafia roleblocker <----- you are not taking this possibility into account. Gaia is mafia
Gav is a *potentially* an NK target for mafia, so not the best use of NK. Also I'd rather not kill one of the few other guys here that is making (mostly) rational decisions. That would make the next day phase living hell.
kingjad is town, gaia is town, gaverion is mafia, gerben is town result of xinde's plan: we lose cop, medic and townie. and assuming that either gav or gaia are mafia, by killing both we get at least a 2-1 trade, potentially being a much better situation.
Like the thing you have to consider here... This game is so bad that mafia could easily win without having to bus PT.
@GabrielQ Actually, Xinde shoots Jad (1 dead Town), I am blocked (No death), and then Gerb dies (two town dead). Although this incriminates the Bane Shift out of me, and Gav will refute my block claim, meaning I will probably get lynched (3 dead). So yeah, only 2 technically.
I find it funny how selfish a number of town players are acting (they have to be town because there are so many of them!). Remember even if you die if you are on the winning side you win!
So, I read through, and I personally feel really, really uncomfortable claiming roles in general, whether it goes against the spirit of the game, or whether there are other people out there trying to push me to counterclaim a role so that way they can really find out who I am, even when I am just a regular townsperson, it's just really, really uncomfortable and historically, I usually see the mafia people trying to get claims out and early. And that is what is surprising to me, really, how many power role claims there are. Seems like just about everyone here has a power. GabrielQ - Mason Gaiaix555 - Doctor Gaverion - Blocker Geressen - Cop KingJad - Townsperson Napalm Monk - Vig Xinde - Vig Even then, most surprising to me of all, I think, is that everyone here that has claimed to be a regular townsperson seemed to be under suspicion, Emries, Qucas, and now KingJad, and each of them has been systematically killed off by the "townspeople" themselves. That's really all I have at the moment, sorry that I can't really add more.