Reproduction Steps: 1. Deploy Firk Soulthief for enemies (today's daily is great for this) 2. Deploy a champion with soften. Elven Page is a good option. 3. Soften the Soulthief. 4. Use magical attack or any other damaging single target ability. 5. The base damage of an attacking champion will be redirected to another target, but the champion with pawn will still take damage equal to amount of negative DEF they have. Proof: @Sokolov